Ed Miliband Resigns After Crushing Loss in British Election
British opposition leader Ed Miliband quit on Friday after his Labor Party suffered a heavy election defeat and was virtually driven out of Scotland, leaving the demoralized party with no obvious successor.
Miliband had gone into Thursday’s election expecting he had a good chance of beating Prime Minister David Cameron’s Conservatives and forming a government, probably in some form of alliance with a smaller party. Instead Cameron will govern again, this time with an overall parliamentary majority.
“Britain needs a Labor Party that can rebuild after this defeat so we can have a government that stands up for working people again,” Miliband said at Labor’s headquarters in London.
“And now it’s time for someone else to take forward the leadership of this party, so I’m tendering my resignation,” said Miliband, who will remain a Labor member of parliament.
Deputy leader Harriet Harman will take over until a new leader is elected, at which point she will in turn resign.
Labor suffered a mauling in Scotland, one of the party’s historic heartlands, where it lost all but one of the 41 House of Commons seats it previously held there to the Scottish National Party.
In addition, Labor failed to capture swing seats in England from the Conservatives, who will now be able to form a single-party government after five years in coalition with the Liberal Democrats.
Miliband said he took sole responsibility for the rout, in which some of Labor’s most senior figures lost their seats.
Ed Balls, who would have been finance minister had Labor won, was defeated in his constituency. Campaign chief Douglas Alexander lost his seat in Scotland, as did Jim Murphy, head of Scottish Labor. Miliband’s exit and Balls’s defeat leave Labor shocked and rudderless with no obvious successor.
WHAT NEXT FOR THE LEFT?
Possible leadership candidates could include Andy Burnham, who was health minister under former Prime Minister Gordon Brown, Yvette Cooper, who was work and pensions minister then, and Chuka Umunna, the party’s spokesman on business since 2011.
It is also possible that a new leader could emerge from the ranks of relative newcomers with fewer links to either Brown or his predecessor Tony Blair, such as members of parliament Dan Jarvis, Tristram Hunt, Liz Kendall or Rachel Reeves.
Miliband himself was a surprise winner in Labor’s 2010 leadership election, beating his older and better known brother David thanks to support from workers’ unions that earned him the nickname “Red Ed.”
A sometimes awkward figure, Miliband was ridiculed as a geek by sections of the press and denounced as a weak leader by Cameron. Where the Conservative leader was seen as an asset to his party, Miliband was presented as a liability.
During the final weeks of the election campaign he was deemed to have outperformed expectations and his personal ratings had shown signs of improving, but the results on the night were a disaster.
Whoever replaces him will have to engage in soul-searching after Labor’s near obliteration in Scotland, which raises questions about how the party can ever win a majority in the House of Commons again.
In the past, Labor usually won the lion’s share of Scotland’s 59 seats and relied on its Scottish members of parliament to make up the numbers necessary to form governments.
In England, Labor failed to gain significant ground from the Conservatives in the places where it mattered most, the swing seats, and lost some support to anti-European Union and anti-immigration party UKIP.
Blair, who won three elections in a row for Labor to be prime minister from 1997 to 2007, said before the election that if Labor presented itself as a traditional left-wing party opposing the right-wing Conservatives, it would lose as had happened in the past.
But Owen Jones, a prominent left-wing author and Labor supporter, said veering to the right would be a bad knee-jerk reaction for Labor.
He said Miliband had failed to articulate a clear message or produce policies that would make a genuine difference to the lives of poorer Britons, the party’s natural base.
“While the Tories (Conservatives) had clear messages, ‘clearing up Labor’s mess’, balancing the books, reforming welfare and so on, Labor never build a coherent alternative,” he wrote in the Guardian.
“There will be a big debate now over the future of the Labor Party, and what the left does next.”
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse.
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
