Elliot Steinmetz: Sports Dad of the Year
Elliot Steinmetz coaching the Yeshiva University Maccabees. By Patrick Smith/Getty Images
By Louis Keene December 24, 2021
This is one of seven profiles of American Jews who fascinated us in 2021. Click here to see all seven and read an explanation of our Forward Shortlist.
When a late-game layup put his team down by one point at Sarah Lawrence in 2020, Elliot Steinmetz, head coach of the Yeshiva University men’s basketball team, surprised fans by not calling a timeout.
“I think my players are better players than I am a coach,” he said later.
His trust was rewarded. The players raced up court and scored just before the final buzzer, notching the team’s 15th straight win. The Maccabees went on to win 35 more in a row (and counting), the second-longest winning streak in college hoops history. Y.U., where Steinmetz lettered and where he has been coaching since 2014, is now the top-ranked Division III team in the NCAA, in hot pursuit of a national championship twice denied them by pandemic cancellations.
Coaching during a 2020 game at the beginning of the streak. By Patrick Smith/Getty Images
Steinmetz’s humility understates his role in the program’s success. Early on, he successfully pitched a cohort of top Jewish high-school players to commit to Yeshiva, then taught them a motion offense that the Maccabees run more sharply than any competitor in the country. Both system and streak have outlasted that cohort.
The team’s historic achievements are only part of Steinmetz’s imprint on this unprecedented year for Orthodox Jewish athletes. In July, his son, Jacob Steinmetz, became the first Orthodox player drafted by Major League Baseball. Selected by the Arizona Diamondbacks with the 77th overall pick, the younger Steinmetz, standing 6-foot-6 in cleats, has a 97 m.p.h. fastball — and a commitment to keeping Shabbat.
Which does not necessarily mean he won’t pitch on Saturdays. During high school, Jacob walked up to five miles on Shabbat to get to tournaments. Here’s hoping he can find an apartment — and a minyan — closer than that to the Diamondbacks’ Chase Field.
“I’m not a big trophy guy, I don’t really care for rings or trophies,” Elliot Steinmetz, who is 41, said in an interview earlier this year. “For me, the goals are always the same: to get better every day, try to win every time you’re out there and to represent the university and the surrounding Jewish community in a positive way.”
In his own words
We asked the seven fascinating people on our Forward Shortlist to answer a few questions unrelated to the work they do.
What do you eat for breakfast?
Coffee.
What app on your Smartphone can you not live without?
My calendar.
What’s your earliest Jewish memory?
Sitting in synagogue on Shabbat mornings with my father.
What’s your favorite holiday?
Maccabee season (Hanukkah). Holiday of miracles and great basketball games.
Who is your hero?
My children. Watching them navigate this difficult and stressful world we are living in with poise, class and minimal complaining is inspiring.
Tell us about a book you read, movie you watched, TV show you streamed or podcast you listened to in 2021 — or one of each!
I don’t watch much TV or many movies. A recent book I read (though probably pre-2021) was “New York,” by Edward Rutherford. It chronicles the birth and growth of New York City from the 17th century onward. I found it to be a brilliant piece of historical fiction that touches on the history of New York City and its diversity as well as the growth of the real estate industry throughout each century.
What’s one thing you always do (or try to) on Friday night or Saturday?
Catch up on sleep.
What’s your New Year’s Resolution?
Win more basketball games, close more real estate deals, but do fewer interviews.
To view the full Forward Shortlist, click here.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse..
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
