In 3 days, NYC handed out 30,000 free kosher meals. It still wasn’t enough.
Loading leftover meals from a distribution center at a north Williamsburg school to take to a MASBIA soup kitchen. Image by Alexander Rapaport
By Ari Feldman April 27, 2020
New York City has handed out nearly 32,000 kosher meals since last Wednesday, but it underestimated the number of meals needed and encountered problems distributing them, including shortages in some locations, surpluses in others and several long lines.
Politicians representing Jewish areas who fought for kosher meals to be added to the city’s free-meal program, run through the Department of Education, criticized the rollout and said it risks humiliating and disappointing people.
“Thursday was a disaster. Friday was a disaster,” said Simcha Eichenstein, a state assemblyman representing the heavily Orthodox neighborhood of Borough Park, and who helped organize the kosher meal program. “It is not acceptable to have 100 people on line, and just turn them away without food — that cannot happen in 2020 in the city of New York.”
In normal times, the Department of Education’s breakfast, lunch and after school meal programs feed about 70 percent of the city’s children. The DOE kept providing those meals when the virus shut down the schools, and then in late March the city decided to use the same mechanism to feed adults, as well.
It will distribute more than 10 million meals in April, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio said last week, but the provision of kosher meals was delayed by Passover, said Sam Levy, head of sales and customer relations at Borenstein Caterers, the company supplying the meals. City rules mandate that the meals include a certain amount of whole grains, and observant Jews can’t eat leaven during that holiday.
New York City neighborhoods with large Orthodox communities had high concentrations of poverty even before the virus hit. According to a 2011 study of Jewish poverty from UJA-Federation of New York, 55% of Jewish households in Williamsburg, and 44% in Borough Park — the two largest Hasidic communities in Brooklyn — were considered poor.
Now, more people are struggling. Alexander Rapaport, the executive director of MASBIA, a network of kosher soup kitchens, said that its three locations are seeing upwards of 7,000 families a week, up from about 2,000 a week before the crisis. Rapaport said he believes the majority of his clients are to be observant Jews.
People waiting on line for kosher food at a location in Brooklyn last week. Image by Sam Levy
Queens-based Borenstein’s main business is supplying kosher meals to airlines and schools. They carry a heksher, or kosher certification, from the Volover Rebbe, Rabbi Nachum Ephraim Teitelbaum, which is accepted even among the most observant of Hasidic Jews, which Rapaport said was a major accomplishment.
“From the procurement level, it’s a breakthrough,” said Rapaport. “At the distribution level, there’s a lot of mismanagement.”
The city advertised the meals with posters in English and Yiddish, and politicians and Orthodox groups that lobbied for the city to provide the meals — such as Councilman Chaim Deutsch and the Orthodox Union — posted about them on social media.
Yet problems emerged when the meals began to be handed out at public schools last Wednesday. In one line, more than 100 people waited hours, while another closed abruptly with dozens still waiting because it had run out of meals.
“Initial demand was larger than anticipated,” said Nathaniel Styer, the Department of Education’s deputy press secretary. The department worked with Borenstein increase production and also added distribution sites starting on Monday.
A kosher breakfast meal. Image by Sam Levy
A lunch meal. Image by Sam Levy
Despite the shortages in some locations, on Friday the city asked Rapaport to pick up leftover meals from distribution centers in Queens and in the Flatbush section of Brooklyn. On Monday afternoon, the city asked him again to pick up as many as 1,350 leftover meals at a Williamsburg school.
The issue Monday, Rapaport guessed, was that the school was more than a mile from the sections of Williamsburg that are densely populated with Hasidic Jews, the target population for the meals. The leftover food will be distributed at MASBIA kitchens this evening, he said.
Eichenstein said that, after notifying the city of the issue in Williamsburg on Monday afternoon, the city was shifting that distribution location, as well as another in Crown Heights, to be closer to Hasidic centers in those neighborhoods.
Levy, of Borenstein Caterers, said that he went to a school in Brooklyn last week to watch the meals being distributed. He was upset to see people leaving empty handed, he said, but also wants everyone to understand that the city and his company worked hard to provide what they could.
“The people that are complaining, I think they really don’t know what happened behind the scenes at DOE, and Borenstein,” he said.
Avi Greenstein, executive director of the Borough Park Jewish Community Council, said that DOE staff have been working hard to respect the cultural standards of the Orthodox community, in some cases by distributing the kosher food at different parts of a school building from the non-kosher food.
“When the city comes out and says we’re going to provide meals in a dignified way, with the highest kashrut levels, people really feel a sense of relief,” Greenstein said.
Click here for a list of city locations where free kosher meals are available.
Ari Feldman is a staff writer at the Forward. Contact him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter @aefeldman
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse.
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
