‘Extrapolations’ gives us an amazing Black rabbi (and a lot of embarrassing white Jews)
Daveed Diggs’ performance moves the Jewish story forward, but tired tropes hold the show back
Marshall Zucker (Daveed Diggs) with a water-pumping robot in Extrapolations. Courtesy of Apple TV+
By PJ Grisar March 15, 2023
The year is 2047. Israel and Palestine coexist peacefully as partner states. A Black rabbi is appealing to the government to rescue his synagogue from rising sea levels. Kanye West is doing interior design for casinos — and investors are excited about it.
Well, at least the rabbi story seems plausible.
The Ye stuff, which somehow manages to make Apple TV+’s new speculative sci-fi series, Extrapolations, feel dated (or perhaps prescient if you’re Elon Musk looking at land in Texas), is not the only place your suspension of disbelief has some mighty work ahead of it. It’s not that the show, which follows the effects of climate disasters from the year 2037 to 2070 through interconnected and some standalone vignettes, has a view of the future that’s particularly far-fetched. It’s mainly that the characters never behave exactly human — and that includes most of the Jews.
One of the more utopian aspects of this dystopia is how little fuss is made over the fact that Daveed Diggs’ Rabbi Marshall Zucker, who appears in part of the first episode and takes up the whole of the third, is heading a congregation. His dwindling flock is mostly white, but no one, including the non-Jewish woman providing pumps for his flooded Miami shul, subjects him to the usual prying questions that Black Jews — and Black Jewish clergy — often face from their coreligionists. (What microaggressions there are are so micro as to be debatable, at least to my eyes.)
Diggs is great in the role and it’s refreshing to see a TV rabbi actually speak some Hebrew, even if it’s between clumsy exposition on the bimah about humans landing on Mars, a cure for cancer and Texas seceding from the Union .
More problematic are the white Jews who surround Marshall. In the first episode, Marshall’s dealmaker father, Ben (Peter Riegert), insists that he abandon his dream of helping climate refugees for the pulpit job he arranged for him. The two have a fight at a hospital when Ben decides he’d rather speak to his clients than be with his wife after she has a near-fatal health emergency. Ben, of course, also blames Marshall for his mother’s condition.
Marshall’s shul board bickers about the temple purse strings in a way that’s scarily accurate, and appropriately frugal given the circumstances, but his newest congregant, Harris Goldblatt (David Schwimmer) ticks far too many bad-guy boxes. Boxes that have some pretty traditional Jewish associations.
Harris is a crooked real estate developer, capitalizing on receding coastlines, bribing city officials and stepping out on his CRISPR plastic surgery-obsessed wife to be with a younger woman. His daughter, Alana (Neska Rose), a sort of Gen Beta prophet of doom, is better, calling out her father’s greed and introducing a fifth question at the family Seder: Why is God is punishing us? But Alana’s concern for the world’s collapse is tainted by tired Jewish American Princess tropes. At one point she considers the following quid pro quo: if she promises to stop hiding her stepmom’s birth control, she can probably convince Harris to pay a kid to move his bar mitzvah date.
It’s pretty incredible that a series that envisions tech that can translate whale songs into English couldn’t dream up more Jews who aren’t familiar stereotypes, or even imagine that, in the mid-21st century, more Jews of color like Marshall might be peopling his pews. Maybe the handful of Black background actors and the all-white shul board are meant as a form of commentary, that, even in two decades from now, Jewish communal life will still be plagued with inclusion issues.
Granted, the show is about humans’ selfishness in the face of disaster, and Marshall’s standalone episode is a kind of retread of the Sodom and Gomorrah story. Marshall handpicks it for Alana’s Torah portion, stressing its message of middah k’neged middah (the punishment fitting the crime, as he explains it). In this analogy, Marshall, who causes unwitting harm after enlisting Harris to save the synagogue, is Lot, the one righteous Jew — even if he’s a Jew who needs to be reminded of his principles by a bat mitzvah.
Extrapolations, for all its talent — Judd Hirsch, Meryl Streep, Edward Norton, Diane Lane, Marion Cotillard, Forest Whitaker and a who’s who of playwrights-turned-TV writers — feels like a preachier version of the excellent BBC drama Years and Years, mixed in with some lesser episodes of Black Mirror.
Putting high concepts above human drama (nearly everyone is just one degree of separation from the president or an Ayn Randian CEO played by Kit Harrington), the few installments that linger on normal people like Marshall are bright spots. It’s also something of a novelty to see the theological aspect of apocalypse through a non-Christian lens.
A certain kind of Christian might welcome the gathering signs of Armageddon. A Jew, in the tradition of Abraham, would challenge God, as Alana does.
In a pre-Pesach sermon, Marshall says, “as Jews we have always seen the question mark as our favorite piece of punctuation.” So true. Extrapolations left me with many questions, but they’re probably not the ones the writers had in mind.
A message from our Publisher & CEO Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
