Moon Knight’s Star of David necklace was easy to miss. It was also a watershed moment for Marvel.
Oscar Isaac in “Moon Knight” Photo by Photo by Csaba Aknay. ©Marvel Studios 2022. All Rights Reserved.
By PJ Grisar April 11, 2022
Amid a blur of hieroglyphs, ankhs and sarcophagi, it was easy to miss a more subtle symbol glinting from Oscar Isaac’s neck in last week’s installment of “Moon Knight.” Unless you happen to be Jewish and watching for signs of Jewish life.
In the final minutes of the episode, Isaac’s Marc Spector wakes up in Egypt, booze bottle in hand, bare-chested and wearing a Magen David necklace, finally settling over a year of speculation as to whether the MCU would acknowledge the character’s Yiddishkeit. It was a discreet, easy to miss gesture, much like the mezuzah on his apartment door earlier in the series. Somehow it still means the world to me.
Was late to Moon Knight’s Apocalypse Now moment (X-Men: Apocalypse Now?!) But dig the Magen David on Marc Spector’s neck! pic.twitter.com/0WnFOzGlbW
— PJ Grisar (@pjgrisar) April 11, 2022
Moon Knight is officially Jewish in the MCU. A Mezuzah can be seen on the door to Steven’s apartment and a Star of David is hanging around his neck. My next hope is that they actually explore that aspect of his identity instead of it just being hinted at. pic.twitter.com/Wmf84oVI6W
— Zack Hartzman: Hey Listen Games (@HeyListenGames) April 7, 2022
For those who don’t know, Moon Knight was born Marc Spector, the son of an Orthodox rabbi and renowned Kabbalist from Czechoslovakia. Apart from Magneto – who is sometimes a Romani and sometimes a Jewish survivor of the Shoah – Spector, who often favors the alias, and, later, dissociative identity, Steven Grant, has perhaps the most Jewish origin story in the mainstream Marvel canon. (Apologies to Sabra.) He’s Jew-ier still than Ben Grimm of Yancy Street and Kitty Pryde, a character better known for sporting a Star of David accessory.
Moon Knight’s Jewish makeup has waxed and waned for decades, with some comics happy to show him wearing a kippah as a child and sometimes as an adult. But if you’ve seen any of the show on Disney+, you can see how those roots might get lost in a forest of competing plot points. “Moon Knight” is also about quarreling Egyptian deities and mental illness, and the show changed the Spector considerably, making his persona of Steven Grant a cockney “gift shopist” and giving him a completely new romantic partner.
It’s perhaps because of all these changes that the man who crafted Moon Knight’s Jewish backstory, a day school principal turned comic book writer named Alan Zelenetz, told me that he wouldn’t be bothered if Moon Knight’s Jewishness didn’t make the cut for the miniseries. And while I was inclined to agree with him, the fact that it did, even in a (so far) tiny way, is huge.
In the ever-bloating Marvel Cinematic Universe, representation is touted by executives, demanded by diverse fans and maligned by a toxic subset of very online nerdom. Missing for the first 14 years of this interconnected story was a visibly Jewish character. This despite the fact that the main architects of this constellation of superheroes were Jewish. The reasons were not so much deliberate as a matter of canon, with Stan Lee, Jack Kirby and Joe Simon making most of their main players gentile. (That and the fact that X-Men and The Fantastic Four, properties that boast the most noteworthy Jews, existed outside the MCU due to other studios owning the film rights.)
But, with Marvel doing better by Asian, Black and – with the coming of Ms. Marvel – South Asian and Muslim fans, Jews of all backgrounds might still feel left out of Marvel’s push for inclusive stories (a push that still bungles up gay content, by the way). Jews had to settle for a limited, Ashkenazi-coded crumb, like when Tony Stark’s dad referenced his fruit seller father and garment worker mother on “Agent Carter.”
I’ve never been one to demand more Jewish content from the Disney corporation (OK, almost never) but now that I’ve caught a glimpse, I realize I missed having it.
Spying Oscar Isaac with some Judaic jewelry thrilled me in a way Marvel properties haven’t been able to in years. I can only imagine how cool it was for Jews of color to see a Latinx actor flaunting a six-pointed star. And who wouldn’t kvell knowing that while the nebbishy Steven Grant is bound up in neuroses and slapstick, his Jewish counterpart is a certified badass?
That Spector would still wear his Jewish bling while serving as the avatar of the Egyptian moon god seems complicated, but invites an interesting conversation about culture, faith and identity that the comics have dealt with to varying degrees of success. Director Mohamed Diab teased a Jewish conclusion to the series. I doubt it will be the meditation on Exodus some are hoping for, and frankly that’s fine by me.
Right now I’m happy for the glimmer of acknowledgment. It’s a small token, but hints at bigger things to come.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
